GitHub Pull Requests is $4/user/mo (Team). Crucible is a self-hosted alternative at $0.99/mo. Here's when each makes sense.
| Crucible | GitHub Pull Requests | |
|---|---|---|
| Hosting | Self-hosted, your infra | Managed SaaS (cloud only) |
| Data location | Your server, your disk | GitHub Pull Requests's cloud |
| Free tier | 3 repos | Paid only |
| Pro pricing | $0.99/mo | $4/user/mo (Team) |
| Dependencies | None (single binary + SQLite) | N/A (managed) |
| Setup time | ~30 seconds | Account signup |
| Dashboard | Built-in at /ui | Cloud dashboard |
| License | BSL 1.1 | Proprietary SaaS |
Crucible is a single Go binary with embedded SQLite. Install it with one command, and you are running in under a minute. Your data stays on your server.
curl -fsSL https://stockyard.dev/crucible/install.sh | sh
Before choosing between Crucible and GitHub Pull Requests, consider what happens when you need to leave. GitHub Pull Requests exports vary in completeness — some fields, some history, some metadata may not come with you. Crucible stores everything in a single SQLite file. Leaving means copying that file. This is not a hypothetical concern: the average team changes tools every 18 to 24 months.
Architecturally, Crucible and GitHub Pull Requests could not be more different. GitHub Pull Requests runs on distributed cloud infrastructure with load balancers, managed databases, CDNs, and redundancy across availability zones. Crucible is a single process writing to a single file on a single disk. That sounds fragile until you realize that SQLite handles more concurrent readers than most web applications will ever need, and WAL mode means reads never block writes.
Switching from GitHub Pull Requests to Crucible is straightforward for most teams. Export your data from GitHub Pull Requests (most services offer CSV or JSON export), then POST each record to Crucible's API. A migration script that reads the export and writes to /api/ endpoints typically takes less than 50 lines of code. The reverse migration is equally simple — Crucible's SQLite database is a standard file you can query with any SQLite client.
Single binary. Free to start. $0.99/mo for Pro.